117-119 N. Olive St., Media, PA 19063
Free Consultation: (610) 891-8303

Last updated November 9, 2026.

A DUI trial in Delaware County takes place in the Court of Common Pleas in Media, where the Commonwealth must prove each element of the charged subsection of 75 Pa.C.S. 3802. A DUI with a maximum of six months is a "petty" offense with no constitutional right to a jury, so a judge decides it (Commonwealth v. Kerry, Pa. Super. 2006). Higher-graded DUIs can go to a jury, which can be waived only if the defendant, the prosecutor and the judge agree (Pa.R.Crim.P. 620).

For our overall approach to drunk driving cases, see our DUI defense page.

When do I have a right to a jury in a DUI case?

The Superior Court explained the test in Kerry, a first-offense general impairment case with a refusal, quoting the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Commonwealth v. Mayberry: crimes carrying a sentence of more than six months are "serious" and those carrying six months or less are "petty," and the jury right does not attach to petty offenses. The court relied on the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Blanton v. North Las Vegas, which held that first-time DUI offenders facing no more than six months are not entitled to a jury trial.

Three points from the opinion matter in practice. Seriousness is judged by the legislature's maximum authorized prison term, and the chance of higher penalties for a later DUI does not change it. Being charged with several petty counts does not create a jury right, even if the combined maximum is over six months. And the Pennsylvania Constitution gives no broader jury right for petty offenses than the federal one.

Charge (examples)Grade and maximumJury?
3802(a) (general impairment or 0.08% to under 0.10%) with no more than one prior offense, unless a 3803(b) or (c) grade appliesMisdemeanor with a maximum of six months (75 Pa.C.S. 3803(a)(1))No constitutional right; tried by a judge (Kerry)
Other DUI charges graded as a misdemeanor with a six-month maximum under 3803(b)(1), (b)(2) or (c)(1), such as a refusal or a 3802(c) or (d) charge with no prior offensesMisdemeanor, maximum six monthsNo constitutional right (same rule)
DUI graded as a misdemeanor of the second or first degreeMaximum of two or five years (18 Pa.C.S. 1104)Yes, unless waived
DUI graded as a felony, such as a third-degree felony under 3803(a)(3) or (a)(4)Maximum of seven years or more (18 Pa.C.S. 1103)Yes, unless waived

The grade on your complaint comes from 3803 and depends on the BAC tier, any refusal, a minor in the car, a crash and prior offenses. The full grading table is on our DUI defense page, and how repeat offenses become felonies is in whether a third DUI is a felony in Pennsylvania.

Can I choose a judge instead of a jury?

Yes, but not alone. Under Rule 620, "the defendant and the attorney for the Commonwealth may waive a jury trial with approval by a judge," and the judge must confirm on the record that the waiver is knowing and intelligent. The waiver must be in writing and signed by the defendant, the prosecutor, the judge and defense counsel. The Pennsylvania Constitution was amended in 1998 to give the Commonwealth "the same right to trial by jury as does the accused," which is why the prosecutor's agreement is needed (Rule 621, Comment).

In a bench trial, the judge decides all questions of law and fact, and the verdict has the same effect as a jury's (Rule 621(A)). Before trial starts, any of the three can withdraw the waiver or the approval (621(B)). After a jury of 12 is sworn and before the verdict, the defendant and the prosecutor may agree, with the judge's approval, to a jury of fewer than 12 but not fewer than 6 (Rule 641). A jury verdict must be unanimous (Rule 648(B)).

What does the Commonwealth have to prove?

  • Driving or control. That you drove, operated or were "in actual physical control of the movement of a vehicle" (3802).
  • For general impairment under 3802(a)(1). That you drank enough alcohol to be "rendered incapable of safely driving." Officers' observations, field tests and driving behavior can be evidence of it.
  • For a BAC tier. That your blood or breath alcohol was in the charged range "within two hours" after driving: 0.08% to under 0.10% (3802(a)(2)), 0.10% to under 0.16% (3802(b)), or 0.16% or higher (3802(c)). The two-hour rule is explained in the two-hour rule for DUI tests.
  • For a drug DUI under 3802(d). The presence of a listed substance or impairment, as the subsection charged requires. What each drug subsection covers is explained in whether a DUI for marijuana or prescription medicine is different.
  • For grading facts. Prior offenses, a refusal, a minor passenger or an accident that raise the grade.

What evidence rules apply at a DUI trial?

  • Test results. Blood or breath results are admissible when the tests "were conducted by qualified persons using approved equipment," and breath tests must use Department of Health approved devices calibrated and tested as the regulations require (75 Pa.C.S. 1547(c)). A certificate or log showing the device was calibrated and accurate is presumptive evidence of those facts (1547(c)(1)), and calibration and procedure records can be a subject of cross-examination.
  • A refusal. The fact of a refusal may be introduced "along with other testimony concerning the circumstances," but "no presumptions shall arise from this evidence" (1547(e)). See what happens if you refused a breath or blood test.
  • Other evidence. The statute does not limit "any other competent evidence" on whether the driver was under the influence (1547(f)).
  • Evidence already excluded. Evidence suppressed before trial, for example after an unlawful stop, cannot be used; how suppression and dismissal arguments work is in whether a DUI can be reduced or dismissed.

How does a DUI trial run, step by step?

  1. Pretrial. After formal arraignment, motions such as suppression are filed and decided; see formal arraignment and the motions that follow it in Delaware County.
  2. Jury or bench decision. If a jury is available, decide whether to waive it; the colloquy and written waiver happen on the record (Rule 620).
  3. Jury selection, if any. Prospective jurors are questioned and selected in the presence of a judge unless all parties waive it with the judge's consent (Rule 631(A)).
  4. The Commonwealth's case. This can include the arresting officer, a test operator or lab witness, and other witnesses.
  5. The defense case. Whether to testify or call witnesses is a decision you make with your lawyer.
  6. Verdict. The judge announces a bench verdict; a jury verdict must be unanimous (Rule 648(B)).
  7. Sentencing and after. Sentence is ordinarily imposed within 90 days of conviction (Rule 704(A)); a post-sentence motion is due within 10 days, and an appeal within 30 days of sentence or the decision on the motion (Rule 720(A)).

Where trial fits in the overall timeline is shown in how long a DUI case takes in Delaware County, and the courthouse itself in what to expect at the Delaware County Courthouse.

What changes the answer?

  • The grade charged. A six-month maximum means a judge decides; higher grades allow a jury (Kerry; 3803).
  • The Commonwealth's position. A jury can be waived only if the prosecutor also agrees (Rule 620).
  • The test evidence. Equipment, calibration and the two-hour window can decide which subsection, if any, is proved (1547(c); 3802).
  • A refusal. It can be admitted, but no presumption arises from it (1547(e)).
  • ARD instead. Choosing ARD avoids trial; the tradeoffs are in whether to accept ARD or fight a DUI.
  • The license. A PennDOT suspension follows its own rules; see when PennDOT suspends your license after a DUI.

For example: a first offense with a disputed breath test

Here is a hypothetical. A driver in Springfield is charged with general impairment under 3802(a)(1) and under 3802(a)(2) after a breath result of 0.09%. It is his first offense. He declines ARD because he believes the stop was unlawful and the breath test was taken more than two hours after driving. His lawyer files a suppression motion, which is denied.

At trial, both counts fall under 3802(a) and carry a six-month maximum under 3803(a)(1), so under Kerry they are tried to a judge without a jury. The defense cross-examines the officer on the reason for the stop and on the timing, and challenges the breath device's calibration records under 1547(c). The judge weighs whether the Commonwealth proved a result of at least 0.08% within two hours and whether the officer's observations proved general impairment. Whatever the verdict, the lawyer explains the 10-day post-sentence deadline. This example is only an illustration; it does not predict any result.

What mistakes do people make about DUI trials?

  • Assuming every DUI gets a jury. Six-month-maximum charges are tried by a judge.
  • Thinking the defense alone can choose a bench trial. The prosecutor and judge must agree (Rule 620).
  • Skipping pretrial motions. A suppression issue not raised in the omnibus pretrial motion is generally deemed waived (Pa.R.Crim.P. 581(B)).
  • Not getting the test records. Calibration, certification and timing records are where test challenges start.
  • Talking about the case. Statements to police, friends or online can become trial evidence.
  • Missing post-trial deadlines. Ten days for a post-sentence motion, 30 days for an appeal (Rule 720).

What should I do this week?

  1. Get the complaint and note each 3802 subsection charged and the grade under 3803.
  2. Write down your timeline: last drink, driving, stop, arrest and test times.
  3. Ask your lawyer to request the test records and any video.
  4. List any prior DUI or ARD, since prior offenses change grade and jury rights.
  5. Note the preliminary hearing or formal arraignment date.
  6. Read our first-week checklist after a DUI arrest and bring the papers to your consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I demand a jury for a first-offense DUI?

Not for a charge with a maximum of six months. In Kerry, the Superior Court held there is no right to a jury for that kind of DUI, following Blanton v. North Las Vegas.

Does having several charges give me a jury?

No. Kerry explains that being charged with several petty offenses does not make them serious, even if the combined maximum exceeds six months.

Who decides my case if there is no jury?

A judge of the Court of Common Pleas decides all questions of law and fact, and the verdict has the same effect as a jury's (Rule 621(A)).

Can my refusal be used against me at trial?

Yes, the refusal can be admitted with testimony about the circumstances, but the law says no presumption arises from it (1547(e)).

How many jurors decide a DUI case?

Twelve, unless the parties agree with the judge's approval to continue with fewer, but never fewer than 6 (Rule 641). The verdict must be unanimous (Rule 648(B)).

Attorney Alessandro Giribaldi handles DUI cases in the Delaware County Courthouse and its district courts, including at trial. Call Giribaldi Law at (610) 891-8303 or contact us online for a free consultation. Evening and weekend appointments are available.

Sources