Last updated November 9, 2026.
No. Once police file a criminal complaint, the case belongs to the Commonwealth, and only the attorney for the Commonwealth (in Delaware County, the District Attorney's office) or a designee can withdraw a charge (Pa.R.Crim.P. 551 and its Comment). The person who called the police can tell the prosecutor what they want, and for certain crimes the law gives them a formal right to be heard before a charge is dropped or reduced, but the decision is the prosecutor's, and once the prosecutor has filed the information (the formal charging document in the Court of Common Pleas) a judge must approve it (Rule 585; 42 Pa.C.S. 8932).
There is one narrower path the alleged victim's wishes can feed into: a dismissal "upon satisfaction or agreement," where the harm has been repaid and the prosecutor consents (Rules 546 and 586). For how criminal cases work from start to finish, see our criminal defense page.
Why can't the alleged victim just drop it?
A criminal case is not a private lawsuit. The complaint accuses the defendant of violating "the penal laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania" (Pa.R.Crim.P. 504), and the person who reported the incident is a witness, not a party. The Crime Victims Act says so directly: its legal standing provisions do not "grant party status to a victim" (Crime Victims Act, section 232(1)).
The Supreme Court's own rule on withdrawals before a district judge was amended in 1995, according to its Comment, "to make it clear that only the attorney for the Commonwealth or a designee has the authority to withdraw a prosecution" (Rule 551, Comment). A police officer who filed the complaint, a magisterial district judge, and the person who called 911 cannot end the case on their own.
That does not make the alleged victim's view irrelevant. In practice, a prosecutor deciding whether a case can be proved may want to know whether the main witness still supports it, what they would say under oath, and whether other evidence (photos, body camera video, 911 audio, medical records, other witnesses) can carry the case without them.
Who decides at each stage of the case?
The answer changes as the case moves from the district court to the courthouse in Media. The steps of a Delaware County case are traced in what happens after an arrest in Delaware County; this table shows who can end a charge at each point.
| Stage | How a charge can end | Who decides | Rule or statute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before the district judge (up to the preliminary hearing) | Written withdrawal of one or more charges | The attorney for the Commonwealth or a designee | Pa.R.Crim.P. 551 |
| Before the district judge, most serious charge a misdemeanor | Dismissal on satisfaction or agreement | The district judge, if the four conditions are met, including consent of the prosecutor (or the affiant, if no prosecutor is present) | Pa.R.Crim.P. 546 |
| Held for court, before the information is filed | Notice of withdrawal filed with the clerk of courts; no court approval needed | The attorney for the Commonwealth | Pa.R.Crim.P. 561(A) and Comment |
| When the information is filed | Any complaint charge left off the information is deemed withdrawn | The attorney for the Commonwealth | Pa.R.Crim.P. 561(B) |
| After the information is filed | Nolle prosequi, ordered in open court; costs may be imposed | The judge, on the prosecutor's motion, even over anyone's objection | Pa.R.Crim.P. 585; 42 Pa.C.S. 8932 |
| In the Court of Common Pleas, no force, violence or threat alleged | Dismissal on satisfaction or agreement | The judge, with the prosecutor's consent | Pa.R.Crim.P. 586 |
The first real test of the evidence is the preliminary hearing, where the Commonwealth must show a prima facie case; how that hearing works is explained in what happens at a preliminary hearing in Pennsylvania.
What is a nolle prosequi?
A nolle prosequi (also called a "nol pros") is the prosecutor's formal decision not to go forward on a charge. Under Rule 585, the court may order it "in open court" on the motion of the attorney for the Commonwealth, "notwithstanding the objection of any person," and the court may impose costs when it does. Section 8932 of the Judicial Code bars the District Attorney from entering a nolle prosequi without court approval once the information has been filed.
Two things follow. First, the alleged victim cannot block a nolle prosequi by objecting, and cannot force one by asking for it. Second, the defendant may be ordered to pay court costs even though the charge is dropped, so the terms should be clear before anyone agrees to it. What fines, costs and fees can look like in this county is laid out in what a criminal case costs in Delaware County.
What is a dismissal "upon satisfaction or agreement"?
This is the one procedure built around the person who was harmed. It exists at two levels.
- Before the district judge (Rule 546). When the most serious charge is a misdemeanor, the issuing authority may dismiss the case on a showing that (1) the public interest will not be adversely affected, (2) the attorney for the Commonwealth consents (or, if no prosecutor is present, the affiant, the person who swore out the complaint, such as the officer), (3) satisfaction has been made to the aggrieved person or there is an agreement that it will be, and (4) there is an agreement on who pays the costs. The Comment says a dismissal under this rule is a dismissal of all the charges, including joined summary offenses.
- In the Court of Common Pleas (Rule 586). The same idea, but only when the offense "is not alleged to have been committed by force or violence or threat thereof." Only a Common Pleas judge may use Rule 586; district judges are limited to Rule 546.
"Satisfaction" can mean paying back a loss, such as damage to a car or property. The person harmed cannot sign off on their own: the prosecutor's consent and the judge's view of the public interest are both required. For charges where force is alleged, such as an assault, Rule 586 is not available in Common Pleas at all, which matters for the charges that can follow a domestic violence arrest.
What rights does the alleged victim have to be heard?
The Crime Victims Act gives victims a voice without giving them control. In cases involving what the Act calls a "personal injury rights crime," or a burglary, a victim has the right to submit prior comment to the prosecutor's office "on the potential reduction or dropping of any charge or changing of a plea," or on diversion of the case (section 201(4), as amended in 2022). In those cases the prosecutor's office must give notice of that opportunity (section 213(b)), and victims can also offer comment, including a victim impact statement, before sentencing (sections 201(5) and 213).
So when a complainant tells the District Attorney's office they no longer want the case to go forward, that comment is something the office considers. It is not a veto, and it does not bind the prosecutor or the court. Delaware County's District Attorney lists outside support agencies, including Delco Victim Assistance, on its victim resources page.
What happens if the witness stops cooperating?
A witness who is unwilling to come to court can be ordered to. A subpoena in a criminal case "shall order the witness named to appear before the court at the date, time, and place specified," and it can be used for a preliminary hearing as well as trial (Pa.R.Crim.P. 107 and Comment). Ignoring a subpoena can lead to a bench warrant for the witness, the same Rule 150 process described in what happens with a bench warrant in Delaware County.
A witness who takes back what they told police faces a different risk. If the first report was knowingly false, the false reports statute applies: falsely incriminating another person is a misdemeanor of the second degree, and reporting an incident the person knows did not occur is a misdemeanor of the third degree (18 Pa.C.S. 4906(a), (b)). That is one reason a complainant who wants to change their account should speak with their own lawyer first, not with the defendant or the defendant's family.
Even when the main witness will not testify, a prosecutor may try to go forward with other evidence. Whether that evidence is enough is a question for the preliminary hearing and, later, for trial.
Can the defendant or the family ask the alleged victim to drop it?
This is where people get into serious trouble. Pennsylvania's witness intimidation statute makes it a crime to intimidate, or attempt to intimidate, a witness or victim into withholding testimony, giving false information, ignoring a subpoena, or staying away from a proceeding, when the person intends or knows that this will interfere with the administration of criminal justice (18 Pa.C.S. 4952(a)).
The grading is severe. The offense becomes a felony if, among other listed factors, the person uses force, violence or deception, threatens force, or offers "any pecuniary or other benefit" to the witness or victim, and the felony grade follows the case: first degree if a first-degree felony or first- or second-degree murder was charged, second degree if the most serious charge is a second-degree felony, third degree otherwise. Without any of the listed factors it is a second-degree misdemeanor (4952(b)). Harming or threatening someone because they acted as a witness or victim is a separate crime, retaliation (18 Pa.C.S. 4953). Witness intimidation is also the only ground on which the rules let a case go to an indicting grand jury instead of a preliminary hearing, as explained in what an indicting grand jury is in Pennsylvania.
In a domestic case there may be a bail condition or a PFA forbidding contact as well, and contact can break it; see what happens if you are accused of violating a PFA. Any discussion about the case should go through lawyers.
What changes the answer?
- The stage of the case. Before the information is filed, the prosecutor can withdraw a charge without the court; after it, a judge must approve a nolle prosequi (Rule 561; Rule 585; 42 Pa.C.S. 8932).
- Whether force or a threat is alleged. Rule 586 dismissals in Common Pleas are not available for offenses alleged to involve force, violence or a threat.
- The grade of the charge. Rule 546 dismissals before a district judge apply only when the most serious charge is a misdemeanor.
- The kind of crime. The victim's formal right to comment on dropping or reducing charges covers "personal injury rights crimes" and burglary (Crime Victims Act section 201(4)).
- Other evidence. Body camera video, 911 recordings, photos, medical records and other witnesses can let the Commonwealth proceed without the complainant.
- Diversion. A case that is not dropped may still qualify for ARD or another program; Delaware County's options are in diversion programs for non-DUI charges in Delaware County.
For example: a damaged car and a change of heart
Here is a hypothetical. After an argument outside a bar in Upper Darby, a man kicks in the door of his friend's car, and the body shop quotes $1,400 to fix it. The friend calls the police, and the man is charged with criminal mischief, a misdemeanor of the second degree because the loss is over $1,000 (18 Pa.C.S. 3304(b)), plus a summary disorderly conduct count. A week later the two have patched things up, and the friend calls the district court to say he wants to "drop the charges." The court tells him it cannot do that.
The man's lawyer contacts the assistant district attorney before the preliminary hearing. The man pays for the body shop repair and brings the paid receipt, the friend confirms he has been paid, and the lawyer asks the prosecutor to consent to a dismissal under Rule 546, with an agreement on who pays the costs. The prosecutor consents and the district judge, finding no harm to the public interest, dismisses the case, including the summary count. Had the man punched his friend instead of the car, Rule 546 could still apply at the district court level for a misdemeanor, but once in Common Pleas, Rule 586 would not, because force was alleged. This example is only an illustration; every case depends on its own facts and on the prosecutor's decision.
What mistakes do people make when they want charges dropped?
- Calling the alleged victim to talk it through. Contact can break a bail condition or a PFA, and a request backed by money or pressure can be charged under 18 Pa.C.S. 4952.
- Offering to "make it right" informally. Repayment should be made through the Rule 546 or 586 process, with the prosecutor's consent and a written agreement on costs, not as a side deal.
- Assuming the case is over because the complainant said so. Missing a court date on that belief can bring a bench warrant.
- Telling a complainant to skip court. Intimidating, or trying to intimidate, a witness into ignoring a subpoena or staying away from a proceeding is listed conduct under 4952(a)(5) and (6).
- A complainant changing the story without advice. A recantation can raise false report questions under 18 Pa.C.S. 4906.
- Forgetting about costs. A nolle prosequi can still come with costs (Rule 585(B)).
What should I do this week?
- Keep every court date on the complaint and the bail order, no matter what the other person says.
- Follow every no-contact term; if you need to communicate about property or children, ask your lawyer how.
- Write down the charges and their grades from the complaint; the Pennsylvania criminal penalties chart shows the maximum for each grade.
- Gather proof of any loss you could repay (repair estimates, receipts) and give it to your lawyer, not to the complainant.
- Note the district court number and preliminary hearing date; Delaware County's courts are listed on our page about Delaware County's district courts.
- Talk with a defense lawyer about whether withdrawal, a Rule 546 or 586 dismissal, or diversion is realistic.
Frequently asked questions
Can the police officer drop the charges?
No. Rule 551 and its Comment give the authority to withdraw a prosecution only to the attorney for the Commonwealth or a designee. When no prosecutor is present at the district court, the officer's consent can satisfy one of the four conditions for a Rule 546 dismissal, but the judge still decides.
Does it help if the alleged victim writes a letter?
It can be part of what the prosecutor considers, and victims of personal injury rights crimes and burglary have a statutory right to comment on dropping or reducing charges. It does not bind the prosecutor or the court.
If the alleged victim does not show up, is the case dismissed?
Not automatically. The Commonwealth may ask for a continuance, subpoena the witness, or try to proceed on other evidence. Whether the evidence presented is enough is decided at the hearing.
Can charges be refiled after they are withdrawn?
Sometimes. When charges are withdrawn or dismissed at or before the preliminary hearing, the attorney for the Commonwealth may reinstitute them by approving, in writing, the re-filing of a complaint (Pa.R.Crim.P. 544(A)). Ask your lawyer before treating any withdrawal as final.
Is a dropped charge still on my record?
The arrest record can remain until it is cleared. Non-conviction records can be expunged by court order (18 Pa.C.S. 9122(a)(2)); see expungement, limited access and Clean Slate in Pennsylvania.
Can I be charged for asking someone to drop the case?
A polite request is not automatically a crime, but intimidating or attempting to intimidate a witness or victim to withhold testimony or stay away from court is, and offering money or another benefit makes it a felony (18 Pa.C.S. 4952). Let your lawyer handle any communication.
Call Giribaldi Law at (610) 891-8303 or contact us online for a free consultation about having charges withdrawn or dismissed.
Sources
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 504: contents of complaint
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 551: withdrawal of charges pending before an issuing authority
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 546: dismissal upon satisfaction or agreement (district court)
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 544: reinstituting charges following withdrawal or dismissal
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 561: withdrawal of charges by the attorney for the Commonwealth
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 585: nolle prosequi
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 586: court dismissal upon satisfaction or agreement
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 107: contents of a subpoena
- 42 Pa.C.S. 8932: nolle prosequi or settlement
- 18 Pa.C.S. 4952: intimidation of witnesses or victims
- 18 Pa.C.S. 4953: retaliation against witness, victim or party
- 18 Pa.C.S. 3304: criminal mischief grading
- 18 Pa.C.S. 4906: false reports to law enforcement authorities
- 18 Pa.C.S. 9122: expungement
- Crime Victims Act (Act 111 of 1998, as amended), sections 201, 213 and 232
- Delaware County District Attorney: victim resources and partners
