117-119 N. Olive St., Media, PA 19063
Free Consultation: (610) 891-8303

Last updated November 16, 2026.

An indicting grand jury is a panel of citizens, sworn in by a Court of Common Pleas, that hears the prosecution's evidence in secret and votes on whether to indict. It can replace your preliminary hearing, but only in a case where witness intimidation "has occurred, is occurring, or is likely to occur" (Pa.R.Crim.P. 556(A)), and only in a court that has petitioned for, and received, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's permission to use one (Rule 556(B) and Comment).

The Comment to Rule 556.2 says an accused in Pennsylvania "ordinarily has the right to a preliminary hearing" before any indictment; the grand jury rules in Chapter 5 Part E are a narrow exception. Our criminal defense page describes the rest of a Pennsylvania criminal case.

How is a grand jury different from a preliminary hearing?

Both answer the same question: whether there is a prima facie case that an offense was committed and that the defendant committed it (Rules 542(D), 556.11(A)(2)). The Comment to Rule 556.11 calls a vote to indict "the functional equivalent of holding the defendant for court following a preliminary hearing."

What differs is who decides and who is in the room. At a preliminary hearing you may be present with a lawyer, cross-examine the Commonwealth's witnesses, call witnesses and testify (Rule 542(C)). How that hearing runs is explained in what happens at a preliminary hearing in Pennsylvania. Before a grand jury, the people allowed in the room during a session are the attorney for the Commonwealth, the alternates, the witness being examined, a stenographer and, "as provided by law," the witness's counsel (Rule 556.9(A)); the supervising judge may also allow others, such as an interpreter or security officers (Rule 556.9(B)). The defendant is not on that list.

QuestionPreliminary hearingIndicting grand jury
Who decidesThe issuing authority, such as a magisterial district judge (Rule 542(D))The grand jury; at least 12 permanent grand jurors must vote to indict (Rules 556.3(E), 556.11(B))
StandardPrima facie case (Rule 542(D))Prima facie case (Rule 556.11(A)(2))
When it is usedThe ordinary path after a criminal complaintOnly where witness intimidation has occurred, is occurring or is likely to occur (Rules 556(A), 556.2(A))
Defendant's rolePresent, may be represented, cross-examine, call witnesses and testify (Rule 542(C))Not among the persons listed as present during sessions (Rule 556.9(A))
HearsayConsidered, and can establish any element (Rule 542(E))Evidence it receives may include "hearsay evidence as permitted by law" (Rule 556.11(A)(2))
Open or closedDecision "publicly pronounced" at the end (Rule 543(A))Secret; violations may be punished as contempt (Rule 556.10(A))
If the evidence falls shortDefendant discharged (Rule 543(B))Complaint dismissed; charges may be reinstituted under Rule 544 (Rule 556.11(G) and Comment)

When can a Pennsylvania court use an indicting grand jury?

Two conditions must both be met. First, the court itself must be allowed to use one. The Comment to Rule 556 explains that the rule was adopted in 2012 and that each judicial district must petition the Supreme Court for permission to resume using the indicting grand jury. The petition comes from the president judge or a designee, who must agree with the district attorney's certificate attached to it (Rule 556(B)(1), (2) and (4)). That certificate must state that witness intimidation has occurred, is occurring or is likely to occur in the judicial district, and that the district attorney believes an indicting grand jury "will remedy the problem of witness intimidation" (Rule 556(B)(5)).

Second, the individual case must qualify. Even in a court that has permission, the Commonwealth must file a motion in each case alleging facts of witness intimidation, and a judge must find probable cause (Rule 556.2(A)). Witness intimidation is also a crime of its own under 18 Pa.C.S. 4952, described in whether the person who called the police can drop the charges.

Delaware County is the 32nd Judicial District. None of the official sources we reviewed for this page says whether the Delaware County Court of Common Pleas has petitioned for, or received, permission to use indicting grand juries, so we do not say either way. The county's posted court materials do mention the subject: its Local Criminal Rule 576.1 on electronic filing excludes "any grand jury materials, except the indicting grand jury indictment or the investigating grand jury presentment" from the legal papers covered by that rule, and a chart attached to its public access rule lists indicting grand jury proceedings among criminal case records with no public access. Neither statement shows that a grand jury has been used here. A defense lawyer can confirm from the docket whether a particular case went by indictment.

How does a case go to a grand jury instead of a preliminary hearing, step by step?

  1. The complaint. The case starts with an arrest or complaint and a preliminary hearing date at the district court. Delaware County's courts are listed in which Delaware County district court will hear your preliminary hearing.
  2. The motion. The attorney for the Commonwealth may move to present the matter to an indicting grand jury "instead of proceeding to a preliminary hearing." The motion alleges facts showing witness intimidation and is presented ex parte, meaning without the defense present, to the president judge or a designee (Rule 556.2(A)(1) and (2)).
  3. The ruling. If the judge finds the allegations establish probable cause of witness intimidation, the judge grants the motion and notifies the issuing authority. The motion and the order granting or denying it are sealed and filed with the clerk of courts (Rule 556.2(A)(3) to (5)).
  4. The district court closes its file. On receiving the notice, the issuing authority cancels the preliminary hearing, closes out the case and forwards it to the Court of Common Pleas, and the case "shall not be remanded" to the district court (Rule 556.2(A)(3)). The papers, including a copy of the notice, go to the clerk within five days (Rule 547(b) and (c)(7)).
  5. The 21-day window. The case must be presented to the grand jury within 21 days of the order, unless the defendant waives grand jury action with the Commonwealth's consent or the Commonwealth elects not to present it. If it is not presented in time, "the defendant is entitled to a preliminary hearing in the court of common pleas" (Rule 556.2(C)).
  6. The presentation. Witnesses are sworn by the foreperson, and everything except deliberations and voting is recorded and transcribed (Rules 556.7(A), 556.8(A)).
  7. The vote. At least 12 grand jurors must vote to indict. The signed indictment goes to the supervising judge, who gives the Commonwealth a copy authorizing it to prepare an information (Rule 556.11(B) to (D)).
  8. The next stage. The Commonwealth files an information, as it does after a case is held for court (Rule 560(A)). Formal arraignment follows, as explained in what happens at formal arraignment in Delaware County.

If the grand jury declines to indict, the foreperson reports that in writing and the supervising judge "immediately shall dismiss the complaint" (Rule 556.11(G)). The Comment adds that the Commonwealth may then reinstitute the charges under Rule 544.

Who sits on an indicting grand jury, and for how long?

The court impanels 23 jurors and 7 to 15 alternates by random drawing; alternates attend but do not deliberate or vote unless made permanent members (Rule 556.3(A) to (C)). Fifteen permanent members are a quorum, and the term ends if the panel drops below 15 (Rule 556.3(E) and (F)). A term may not exceed 18 months, extensions come six months at a time, and no term may run past 24 months (Rule 556.5). Every juror swears to keep secret "all that transpires in the jury room except as authorized by law" (Rule 556.6(B)), and the president judge may order a sitting investigating grand jury to serve as the indicting grand jury (Rule 556.1(A)).

What rights does a person indicted this way still have?

An indictment does not end the defense. A defendant may challenge the grand jury as not lawfully drawn, summoned or selected, or a juror as not legally qualified (Rule 556.4(A)). After the information is filed, a defendant may move to dismiss it for an objection to the grand jury or a juror, because the evidence did not establish a prima facie case, for lack of jurisdiction, or because the statute of limitations expired (Rule 556.4(B)(1)). These motions are made "as part of the omnibus pretrial motion" (Rule 556.4(C)), and the Comment says the rule does not limit habeas corpus review.

Discovery follows Rule 573, except that it "does not include testimony or other evidence that would disclose the identity of any witness or victim who has been intimidated, is being intimidated, or who is likely to be intimidated," which is released only as the supervising judge orders (Rule 556.10(B)(5)). The Comment states that the Commonwealth has an affirmative duty to give the defendant exculpatory grand jury testimony and physical evidence under Brady v. Maryland. Disclosure of a witness's testimony may be delayed, but not past the end of that witness's direct testimony at trial (Rule 556.10(B)(3)(b)). A defendant may also waive grand jury action with the Commonwealth's consent and the judge's approval; a represented defendant who does so gives up later challenges to the prima facie case unless the parties agreed, in writing or on the record, to preserve them (Rule 556.12).

Is an indicting grand jury the same as an investigating grand jury?

No. An investigating grand jury comes from the Investigating Grand Jury Act, 42 Pa.C.S. 4541 and following sections. A district attorney may apply to the president judge to summon a county investigating grand jury when its investigative resources are needed to investigate criminal activity in the county (42 Pa.C.S. 4543(b)). It can compel witnesses and documents and issue a presentment, a "written formal recommendation" that specific persons be charged with specific crimes (4542, 4548(b)). Under section 4548(c), "Except for the power to indict," it has every power of any other grand jury.

The indicting grand jury rules "do not apply to any county, regional, or statewide investigating grand jury" (Rule 556 Comment), though an indicting grand jury may indict on a presentment from one (Rule 556.11(A)(2)). The Delaware County District Attorney's divisions page names a deputy district attorney in its Special Investigations Unit as supervising attorney for the Delaware County Investigating Grand Jury program, overseeing investigations into fraud, public corruption, economic and white-collar crimes, police use-of-force cases and labor-related matters. That page describes an investigating grand jury program, not an indicting grand jury.

What changes the answer?

  • The court's permission. A grand jury can replace the preliminary hearing only in a judicial district that has petitioned the Supreme Court, with the district attorney's certificate, and received permission (Rule 556(B) and Comment).
  • The intimidation allegation. The motion must allege facts, and the judge must find probable cause, that witness intimidation has occurred, is occurring or is likely to occur (Rule 556.2(A)).
  • Timing. If the case is not presented within 21 days of the order, or the Commonwealth elects not to present it, the preliminary hearing is held in the Court of Common Pleas (Rule 556.2(C) and Comment).
  • A waiver. Waiving grand jury action can give up the prima facie challenge unless the agreement preserves it (Rule 556.12(A)).
  • Someone not yet charged. A grand jury may indict another person only for an offense from the same criminal conduct or episode; that person is arrested on the supervising judge's warrant and, if arrested in that judicial district, given a preliminary arraignment before the supervising judge or another judge the president judge designates (Rules 556.11(A)(3) and (E), 556.13(A)). Release conditions are described in how bail works in Pennsylvania.
  • The speedy trial clock. For a newly indicted person, the Comment to Rule 556.11 says the filing of the complaint "marks the beginning of the time period for speedy trial under Rule 600"; that clock is explained in how long a criminal case can take under Rule 600.

For example: a cancelled preliminary hearing

Here is a hypothetical, set in an imaginary Pennsylvania county whose court has received the Supreme Court's permission. A man is charged with aggravated assault after a fight outside a bar, and his preliminary hearing is set at the district court. A week before the hearing, the district court cancels it and forwards the case to the Court of Common Pleas. The Commonwealth had filed a sealed motion saying that a witness received threats, and a judge found probable cause of intimidation.

His lawyer tracks the 21-day window under Rule 556.2(C). The grand jury hears the bartender and a police officer, including some hearsay, and 14 jurors vote to indict. After the information is filed, the lawyer's omnibus pretrial motion asks to dismiss it for lack of a prima facie case, while the supervising judge decides when evidence identifying the threatened witness is released. This example is only an illustration and does not predict any result.

What mistakes do people make about grand juries?

  • Assuming a cancelled hearing means the case is over. A cancellation after a grand jury order means the case has moved to the Court of Common Pleas, not that it was dismissed (Rule 556.2(A)(3)).
  • Confusing the two kinds of grand jury. An investigating grand jury's presentment is a different process from an indictment that replaces a preliminary hearing (42 Pa.C.S. 4548; Rule 556 Comment).
  • Missing the omnibus motion. Challenges to the grand jury and motions to dismiss the information must be made as part of the omnibus pretrial motion (Rule 556.4(C)).
  • Signing a waiver without reading it. An unconditional waiver of grand jury action can end the right to challenge the prima facie case (Rule 556.12).
  • Contacting witnesses about the case. Witness intimidation is a separate crime (18 Pa.C.S. 4952); let lawyers handle any contact.
  • Ignoring grand jury secrecy. No one may disclose a matter occurring before the grand jury except as the rules allow, and a violation may be punished as contempt of court (Rule 556.10(A)).

What should I do this week?

  1. Write down your preliminary hearing date and any notice that it was cancelled.
  2. Give your lawyer every court paper, so the docket can be checked for a grand jury order.
  3. If a grand jury order was entered, note the date and count 21 days under Rule 556.2(C).
  4. Follow every bail condition, especially any order to stay away from a witness.
  5. Do not discuss the case with witnesses, on social media or by text.
  6. If you cannot afford a lawyer, read whether you qualify for a public defender in Delaware County and apply right away.
  7. Look up unfamiliar words on your papers, such as "information" or "held for court," in our Pennsylvania criminal court glossary.

Frequently asked questions

Can I testify or present evidence to the grand jury?

The rules do not list the defendant among the people present during grand jury sessions (Rule 556.9(A)). They do provide that a defendant who has testified about the subject matter of the charges may apply for a transcript of that testimony (Rule 556.10(B)(2)). Whether to testify is a decision to make with your lawyer.

Can the grand jury rely on hearsay?

Yes, within limits. Rule 556.11(A)(2) allows an indictment based on evidence "including hearsay evidence as permitted by law," and its Comment cites Commonwealth v. Dessus on that point. Hearsay is also considered at preliminary hearings under Rule 542(E).

How many jurors have to agree to indict?

At least 12 permanent grand jurors must vote to indict, out of a quorum of at least 15 (Rules 556.3(E) and 556.11(B)). Alternates do not vote unless appointed as permanent members (Rule 556.3(C)).

Can my case go back to the district court for a preliminary hearing?

No. Once a case is forwarded to the Court of Common Pleas under a grand jury order, it "shall not be remanded" to the issuing authority (Rule 556.2(A)(3)(b)). If the case is not presented to the grand jury within 21 days, or the Commonwealth elects not to present it, the preliminary hearing is held in the Court of Common Pleas instead (Rule 556.2(C) and Comment). A defendant who waives grand jury action instead consents to be bound over to court (Rule 556.12(A)).

Is a grand jury indictment public?

Not always. The Commonwealth may ask the supervising judge to seal the indictment (Rule 556.11(F)), and grand jury records, orders and subpoenas are kept under seal (Rule 556.10(C)), as are the motion and order sending a case to the grand jury (Rule 556.2(A)(4)).

Where would a Delaware County case go after a grand jury order?

A case forwarded under a grand jury order goes to the Court of Common Pleas (Rule 556.2(A)(3)(a)), which for Delaware County sits in Media. The buildings and offices are described in what to expect at the Delaware County Courthouse.

Call Giribaldi Law at (610) 891-8303 or contact us online for a free consultation about a grand jury order, an indictment or a cancelled preliminary hearing.

Sources