Last updated November 9, 2026.
A Pennsylvania judge chooses a sentence within the legal maximum for the grade of the crime, after considering the Sentencing Guidelines, the protection of the public, the impact on the victim and the community, and the defendant's rehabilitative needs (42 Pa.C.S. 9721(b)). The guidelines give a recommended starting point based on how serious the offense is and the person's prior record, but they are advisory: the judge must consider them, may sentence above or below them, and must state the reasons on the record.
For offenses committed on or after January 1, 2024, the Eighth Edition of the guidelines applies (204 Pa. Code Chapter 303a, the source of every guideline rule quoted on this page). For the maximum penalty attached to each grade, see our Pennsylvania criminal penalties chart; for our overall approach to criminal cases, see our criminal defense page.
What does the law tell the judge to weigh?
Section 9721 of the Sentencing Code lists the alternatives a court may choose from and the principles for choosing. The court must follow the general principle that the sentence should be consistent with "the protection of the public, the gravity of the offense as it relates to the impact on the life of the victim and on the community, and the rehabilitative needs of the defendant" (9721(b)). The court "shall also consider" the guidelines adopted by the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing.
Two duties follow from the same subsection. In every felony or misdemeanor case, the judge must state the reasons for the sentence in open court, as part of the record. And when the sentence falls outside the guidelines, the court must give the Commission a contemporaneous written statement of the reasons for the deviation. Those reasons matter later, because they are what a higher court reviews if the sentence is challenged.
The guidelines themselves describe their role plainly: they "are advisory, and courts are required to individualize sentences." They also quote the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Commonwealth v. Walls, which said the guidelines "recommend, however, rather than require a particular sentence."
How do the guidelines work, step by step?
- Offense Gravity Score (OGS). Each conviction offense is assigned a score that measures its seriousness. The Eighth Edition has 30 general OGS categories, OGS 1 through OGS 30, plus eight categories used only for murder. The OGS is "the primary determinant of the guideline sentence recommendation."
- Enhancements. The OGS can be increased when the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that a listed sentencing factor was present, such as possessing or using a deadly weapon.
- Prior Record Score (PRS). The court looks at the most serious earlier adjudication or conviction and how many of equal seriousness there are. There are five PRS categories, PRS 0 through PRS 4. Some older offenses can drop out of the count after set periods of "decay or gap."
- The recommendation. The OGS and PRS together point to an offense-specific recommendation with a standard range, plus aggravated and mitigated ranges.
- Aggravating and mitigating circumstances. The court considers the circumstances of the offense and the history and character of the person before choosing where in, or outside, the ranges to sentence.
- The whole case. When there are several convictions, the court decides whether sentences run concurrently or consecutively and whether any sentencing or correctional programs fit the aggregate sentence.
- The record. The guideline sentence form, the sentence and any reasons for leaving the standard range are made part of the record and sent to the Commission no later than 30 days after sentencing.
What are the sentencing levels?
The Eighth Edition groups recommendations into eight levels, A through H, each tied to the kind of sentence the guidelines recommend considering.
| Level | What the guidelines recommend considering |
|---|---|
| A | Restorative sanctions: guilt without further penalty, a fine or community service, restitution, or administrative probation of no more than six months |
| B | Probation, with the minimal control needed to fulfill court-ordered obligations |
| C | Confinement in a county facility, or an equivalent period of probation with restrictive conditions when eligible and appropriate |
| D | Confinement in a State facility, with county confinement when authorized by statute or restrictive probation when eligible and appropriate |
| E | Confinement in a State facility |
| F | Confinement in a State facility, for offenses with a statutory maximum over 20 years |
| G | Confinement in a State facility, for third-degree murder (40-year statutory maximum) |
| H | Confinement in a State facility, for first- and second-degree murder and offenses with the same penalty |
The ranges have fixed widths at each level. At Level B, for example, the aggravated range adds six months of general probation to the standard recommendation and the mitigated range subtracts six months. Where the time is actually served also depends on the maximum term the judge imposes, as the confinement section of our penalties chart explains (42 Pa.C.S. 9762).
What counts as an aggravating or mitigating circumstance?
The guidelines list factors the court "may consider, but is not limited to" when it sentences in the aggravated or mitigated range or departs from the guidelines. They fall into two groups.
- The offense. Whether the conduct caused or threatened serious harm, whether another person substantially influenced it, strong provocation, the person's role, abuse of a position of trust, the vulnerability of the victim, and patterns over time.
- The person. No history of criminal conduct, a substantial period of law-abiding behavior, circumstances unlikely to recur, likely good response to probation, excessive hardship from imprisonment, acceptance of responsibility, substantial assistance, having compensated the victim or community, character and attitude, and treatment for substance use, behavioral health issues, developmental disorders or disability.
This list is the practical map of what a sentencing presentation can address. Records of treatment, employment letters, proof that restitution has been paid, and a realistic plan for supervision are how those factors are shown.
What is a pre-sentence investigation, and do I get one?
A pre-sentence investigation report gives the judge information about the circumstances of the offense and the character of the defendant, and it must include a victim impact statement as provided by law (Pa.R.Crim.P. 702(A)(3), (4)). The judge may order one in any case. If the judge decides not to order one where incarceration of a year or more is possible, where the defendant is under 21 at conviction or plea, or where the defendant is a first offender, the judge must put the reasons on the record (702(A)(2)).
In Delaware County, Adult Probation and Parole Services lists pre-sentence investigations among its duties, along with intake interviews, supervision of county probation, parole and ARD, and collection of court fees and restitution. Sentencing for cases held for court takes place at the Court of Common Pleas in Media, described in what to expect at the Delaware County Courthouse.
When does sentencing happen, and what can I do after?
| Step | Timing | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Sentencing | Ordinarily within 90 days of conviction or plea; a delay for good cause must be put on the record with a specific period | Pa.R.Crim.P. 704(A) |
| Post-sentence motion (for example, to modify the sentence) | Written motion no later than 10 days after sentence | Pa.R.Crim.P. 720(A)(1) |
| Appeal after a timely post-sentence motion | Within 30 days of the order deciding it, or of its denial by operation of law, or of its withdrawal | Pa.R.Crim.P. 720(A)(2) |
| Appeal with no post-sentence motion | Within 30 days of the sentence | Pa.R.Crim.P. 720(A)(3) |
The 10-day window is short. If you believe the judge misapplied the guidelines or overlooked a mitigating fact, that point should be raised at sentencing or in a timely post-sentence motion, and your lawyer can tell you which issues need to be raised there. Where the sentencing step falls in a full case timeline is shown in how long a DUI case takes in Delaware County and, for other charges, how long a criminal case can take under Rule 600.
Where do the guidelines not apply?
The guidelines say they do not apply to ARD, a disposition in lieu of trial, direct or indirect contempt of court, violations of protection from abuse orders, or revocation of probation or parole except as their resentencing chapters provide. So a PFA contempt case is sentenced under the PFA Act, not the guidelines; see what happens if you are accused of violating a PFA. Probation revocations follow their own resentencing guidelines, a topic for our page on probation violations in Pennsylvania.
Mandatory minimums are the other limit. The court "has no authority to impose a sentence less than that required by a mandatory minimum provision established in statute," and when the guideline range is lower, the mandatory minimum controls. Repeat DUI sentences are one example; see whether a third DUI is a felony in Pennsylvania.
What changes the answer?
- The date of the offense. Editions apply to offenses committed on or after their effective date; the Eighth Edition took effect January 1, 2024, and offenses committed on several dates are scored by the date of each offense.
- The exact conviction offense. A plea to a lower-graded or different charge changes the OGS, which is why plea terms matter.
- Prior record. More serious or more numerous prior convictions move the PRS category up; certain old offenses can drop off after the periods of decay or gap the guidelines set.
- Enhancements. Findings such as possessing or using a deadly weapon raise the OGS.
- Merger. When crimes merge for sentencing, the court considers the guidelines only on the offense with the higher OGS.
- Mandatory minimums. A statute can set a floor the guidelines cannot go below.
For example: a first felony theft conviction
Here is a hypothetical. A 30-year-old in Havertown with no prior record pleads guilty to a third-degree felony theft charge in the Delaware County Court of Common Pleas. The judge orders a pre-sentence investigation. Her offense is scored under the Eighth Edition because it happened in 2025, and with a Prior Record Score of 0 the guideline form shows a standard range recommendation, with aggravated and mitigated ranges on either side. How theft charges are graded and defended is covered on our theft charges page.
At sentencing, her lawyer presents proof that she has repaid most of the loss, a letter from her employer, and records of counseling she started after the arrest: three of the mitigating factors the guidelines list (no history, compensated the victim, treatment). The victim's statement is in the pre-sentence report. The judge sentences her to probation with restitution of the balance and states the reasons on the record, and the guideline sentence form is sent to the Commission. Her lawyer notes the 10-day deadline for any post-sentence motion. This example is only an illustration; every sentence depends on the facts, the record and the judge.
What mistakes do people make at sentencing?
- Looking only at the statutory maximum. The maximum is the ceiling; the guideline form is where the real discussion starts.
- Arriving with nothing in hand. Mitigating factors have to be shown, not just described: treatment records, proof of payment, employment and family letters.
- Ignoring the pre-sentence interview. What you tell the probation officer goes into the report the judge reads.
- Misjudging the prior record. Old out-of-county or juvenile matters can count; check the record score before a plea.
- Missing the 10-day window. A post-sentence motion filed late can lose issues that could have been raised.
- Assuming a plea deal binds the judge. Before taking the plea, the judge must confirm you understand that the judge "is not bound by the terms of the tendered plea agreement unless the judge accepts the plea agreement" (Pa.R.Crim.P. 590).
What should I do this week?
- Get the exact statute and grade of every charge you face or have pleaded to.
- List every earlier arrest, conviction and juvenile adjudication you have, with dates and counties.
- Start gathering proof of employment, family responsibilities, treatment and any repayment.
- If a pre-sentence interview is scheduled, prepare for it with your lawyer.
- Write down the sentencing date and count 10 days from it for any post-sentence motion.
- Ask your lawyer to walk you through the guideline form before the hearing; our first-week checklist after a criminal charge lists the papers to bring.
Frequently asked questions
Do the guidelines decide my sentence?
No. The court must consider them, but they are advisory. The judge may sentence in the standard, aggravated or mitigated range, or outside the guidelines with written reasons (42 Pa.C.S. 9721(b)).
What is the difference between my minimum and maximum?
A Pennsylvania confinement sentence has both, and the minimum cannot exceed half the maximum (42 Pa.C.S. 9756(b)(1)). The minimum generally cannot be shortened through parole unless the law authorizes it (9756(b)(2)).
Can I get probation for a felony?
It depends on the offense, the record score and any mandatory minimum. Lower sentencing levels recommend restorative sanctions or probation, and restrictive probation can be an alternative at Levels C and D when eligible and appropriate. Once probation starts, the rules for ending it before the full term are in whether probation can end early in Pennsylvania.
Does the victim get a say?
Yes. The pre-sentence report includes a victim impact statement, and victims can offer comment before sentencing under the Crime Victims Act; see whether the person who called the police can drop the charges for how victim comment works earlier in the case.
Do the guidelines apply to ARD?
No. ARD is a diversion, and the guidelines expressly exclude it. Delaware County's options are in diversion programs for non-DUI charges in Delaware County.
Where can I find the official guidelines?
They are published in 204 Pa. Code Chapter 303a, and the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing explains how they work on its website.
Call Giribaldi Law at (610) 891-8303 or contact us online for a free consultation before a plea or sentencing hearing.
Sources
- 42 Pa.C.S. 9721: sentencing generally
- 42 Pa.C.S. 9756: sentence of total confinement
- 42 Pa.C.S. 9762: place of confinement
- 204 Pa. Code Chapter 303a: sentencing guidelines, 8th edition
- Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing: sentencing guidelines
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 590: pleas and plea agreements
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 702: aids in imposing sentence (pre-sentence investigation)
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 704: procedure at time of sentencing
- Pa.R.Crim.P. 720: post-sentence procedures and appeal
- Delaware County Adult Probation and Parole Services
